Year 1 (2003)
Glitter Celebration Ponies

Sparkleworks - I'm very pleased to have my favorite childhood pony again. ❤
Rainbow Ponies

Rainbow Dash
Playset Ponies

Cotton Candy
Seasonal Celebration/Promo Packs?

Butterscotch - I cannot for the life of me place this girl. Multiple Butterscotch releases can have a misplaced hoof heart, but this one also has a magnet so all I know is that she's an earlier release. For now, she lives here :)
Year 2 (2004)
Pony Packs

Lickity Split

Sew-and-so

Tink-a-tink-a-too - I'm actually not sure if this is a Year 1 or Year 2 version, so I just put her here for now :)

Wing Song
Perfectly Ponies

Piccolo
Pretty Pony Fashions

Star Swirl - I think this is the 2004 one, based on her eyes? Kind of hard to tell the difference for me in online pics.
Sparkle Ponies

Forsythia - I got Forsythia and Desert Blossom at the 2024 Maryland Pony Meet, finally crossing these gorgeous ponies off my list! Awesome designs.

Desert Blossom
Year 3 (2005)
McDonald's Toys

Minty

Butterscotch

Wysteria

Pinkie Pie

Daisyjo
Jewel Birthday Ponies

January Joy
Shimmer Ponies

Shell-Belle

Strawberry Reef

Waterfire - what a unique pony :D
Wing Wishes

Toola Roola
Year 4 (2006)
Pegasus Ponies

Morning Monarch
Cutie Cascade Ponies

Comet Tail
Unicorn Ponies

Lily Lightly - I so wish her dress could be easily temporarily removed. I really like her cutie mark and her whole design.
Balloon Flying Ponies

Merriweather - I think this pose suits her more than her first release in the Diva pose, tbh!
Birthday Ponies

March Daffodil - she looks like such a sweetheart!
Year 5 (2007)
Best Friends Ponies

Butter Pop

Pretty Pop

Paradise Island
Unicorn Ponies

Gardenia Glow
Halloween Ponies

Fun Fairy
Favorite Friends Ponies

Sunny Daze
Easter Ponies

Bashful Bonnet
Year 6 (2008)
Favorite Friends

Toola Roola
McDonald's Toys

Pinkie Pie

Toola-Roola

Sweetie Belle

Rainbow Dash

Starsong

Minty